Alright, let’s do this!
In celebration of the new Bleach anime, I am continuing to read and review the VAST quantity of doujinshi (fan produced works) of this manga/anime that exist out there.
Same deal as the previous review. I will do my level best to put these doujinshi into context and try to comment on whether or not they would be at all enjoyable for a non-Bleach fan to read. But, as I stated before, I am SOAKING in this fandom, so I might not always realize which bits of canon are impenetrable (as it were!) or baffling to the outsider.
Here we go….
SPOILERS
.
.
.
.
I’m going to start with my favorite pairing: Renji and Byakuya. This is a couple that really should not go together. They are, in canon, an extreme version of red oni (Renji) and blue oni (Bykauya.) Like, they’re not even in the same social class, Byakuya being a nobleman’s noble and Renji coming from one of the furthest slums from “the capitol” such as it is in the Soul Society, the Seireitei. Byakuya is refined; Renji is crude. In the manga/anime, they are paired together as captain (Byakuya) and lieutenant (Renji,) but, in canon, Renji commits extreme insubordination by choosing to help the hero, Ichigo, save Rukia, and is nearly killed by Byakuya. So, I mean, there really should be no sparks here.
Except there are.
I will not make my entire case as to why this ship has a basis of possibility in canon because it would take up the whole review, and, really, who cares? People ship ships for ship reasons, it is not for us to question why. Byakuya x Renji has a fair amount of doujinshi, however. So, let’s review them.
First up is Yopparai / Drunkard by Nata. I love Nata’s artwork. A piece of theirs has been an inspiration for my own fan work, so I’m definitely biased. This story looks like it was published as part of a Bleach fan book. It also might read as kind of stilted since the notes at the end include the line “this author was not fluent in Japanese and so some of her wording may have been lost in translation.” So, I am assuming this is an English translation of the Japanese translation of the original in whatever language Nata *is* fluent in.
So, the story doesn’t make a huge amount of sense. Basically, at some point after the Fullbring arc (you can tell by Renji’s updated outfit,) Renji and Byakuya have moved in together. They are not “out” as a couple because at one point, Renji makes up a ridiculous story as to why Byakuya is sporting a hickie when Captain Unohana (for non-Bleach folks, imagine: local head healer) inquires if he’s been injured in some way. Most of the story is played for these kind of awkward laughs. Including a scene that most of the ByaRen community agrees is fanon:
Which is that Renji is the kind of drunk to fall asleep, spraling, in the middle of trying to seduce Byakuya… and that he snores.
The sex in this is near the end of the chapter and is censored. Nata imagines Renji as the top. (I will be noting this because it is a matter of some contention in the fandom.) I don’t think that a non-Bleach fan would get much out of this particular doujinshi. The sex is… okay? But not all that hot if you don’t know these characters.
Nata also published Doushouimu / How to Play which is one of the few doujinshi that I’ve read that takes place in the chapters that are currently being animated, which is to say the final “Thousand Year Blood War” arc. This one is entirely a character study.
Next is Hiiragi / The Holly Tree by Yuuago. Guessing through context (and outfits,) this doujinshi takes place in the Soul Society in a time before the action of the Bleach manga begins. There is sex in it but the imagery is not terribly explicit. Yuuago imagines Byakuya as the top and, consequentially, draws Renji must more slender and smaller than he is in canon. The story mostly seems to be a kind of sweet “what if…?” explorations that presumes that the insubordination that I mention at the beginning of this review would be even more bittersweet if Byakuya and Renji were lovers. I only guess that because of this line, which reads: “Someday, the day will come… when you bare your fangs at me.”
Side note, I love the expression of Byakuya in this one tiny panel. It’s a Byakuya we’ve never seen. The “hey, how you doin’?” Byakuya. Mr. Smooth seductor.
At any rate, Red Idol is not for the uninitiated. The jokes will not make sense. However, the smut at the very end might worth skipping to, if you are a fan of kinbaku and sex toys.
Next up is I Know How Grass Holds in a Strong Wind by Inushiro Pochi (Crispy Dog). This one is drawn entirely in the chibi style, so it was very hard for me to get into. Still there are a few funny moments in the story and a very plausible hurt-comfort scenario, where Renji catches a cold and Byakuya takes care of him. If I liked chibi style, I might find this adorable, but I really don’t. Mileage may vary. Probably only for the Bleach enthusiast, since there is zero sex.
It Hesitates by Nanami Kasuga and Triple Star is probably the first ByaRen doujinshi that I could recommend to someone completely unfamiliar with the anime/manga. The story is very self complete and follows a very sexually frustrated Renji who believes he has no hope to bed his captain. By chance, he runs into Yoruichi (a woman who is also a cat, don’t ask,) who offers Renji a tea that is an aphrodisiac that will melt even the iciest ice queen. Renji brews it up, sets it in front of Byakuya, but then decides he can’t possibly use his beloved this way. As a “reward” for his honesty, Byakuya slams it and says, “Take me I’m yours.” There’s a lovely twist at the end that makes the whole thing quite sweet.
The art is FINE. Byakuya is the bottom and, as seems to be required by the artists, is suddenly tiny and girlish in his figure, but the story is actually worth it in this one, in my opinion.
Lovers by Kurumi Mashio is a sweet story that might also be fine for those unfamiliar with the manga. The only thing you need to know going in is actually explained in the story and that is that Byakuya, in canon, was married and lost his wife to a tragic illness. Lovers tells the story of how Byakuya finds love with his doofy, overbearing lieutenant. The art in this one is also in what I would consider the OKAY range, the sex is plentiful (Byakuya is the bottom), and the romantic aspects are fairly sweet, if you find pleasure in the “finding love again after loss” trope.
There is a very strange Byakuya and Renji in the Human World doujinshi called Byakuya-sensei and Renji-kun by Fumitshuki Nana. There is sex (Renji bottoms) but the art is very… mmm, not the best. The story is also just sort of odd, but maybe that would mean it might appeal to people unfamiliar? Not certain.
The final Renji x Byakuya that I’ll review is actually a Renji x a lot of guys including Byakuya, called Assemblage by Koiwazurai Shibito (Super Nova), which is notable for this particularly funny moment in which Ichigo is impressed by how popular Renji is:
If you read Assemblage there are a number of other pairings collected in the manga, including a Keigo x Mizuiro.
I feel like there were a bunch more of these Byakuya x Renji doujunshi out there, but my Google Fu failed me and I was unable to find any of the ones that I half-remembered (or dreamed) existed. If you know of some good ones that I’m missing, let me know.
I will also link to a very rare pairing, Akon x Grimmjow, which never got a translation, apparently titled: Depths of Love of the Conscious Demon by Tommy and MatsuYoi. You can check out the raws here: https://cherry-toxic.tumblr.com/post/43902346174/bleach-doujinshi
I think, once again, I will stop here for now. The next largest pairing for doujunshi seems to be Ichigo x Ishida, so that should probably be my next set. I will try to drop in more rare pairs into each of these, since otherwise I may never get through them all.
Meanwhile, another episode of Bleach canon anime drops today. Enjoy!