Hanayome-kun / Mr. Flower Bride by Lily Hoshino


And now for something completely different…

Of the yaoi books I picked up at Barnes & Noble the other day, Hanayome-kun/Mr. Flower Bride was one. (You can find it for yourself on Mangagogo: http://www.mangago.me/read-manga/hanayome_kun/)

I… I don’t even know what to tell you about this one, but… okay…. here goes nothing.





I can’t believe I’m about to say this, but… the set-up of this story has a weird amount of milage.  I mean, I spent far too much time as I was falling asleep imagining different scenarios in the universe where this exists… and I had far better uses for my brain space, for real.

What we have in Hanayome-kun/Mr. Flower Bride is the Souda family, who are described on the back of the volume as ‘powerful,’ and who have a very ancient, very WTF tradition, which goes like this, “If the eldest son becomes a father to a son, his younger brothers must marry a male in order to prevent disputes over family succession.”


*raises hand*  I have a few questions.  The first of which is what the hell does the Souda family even do? Are they mafia? Because seriously what kind of ‘power’ do you have to wield for this to have worked ‘through the generations’?????  Because, it’s not just forced marriage, it’s forced GAY marriage.

But, of course, none of that ever discussed in the manga. Even though that’s the question that kept me up half the night.  That, and the fact that when we’re introduced to Uno (the flower bride himself) he’s apparently been preparing for this ‘job’ by taking ikebana and cooking classes.

I think this is the part that had me like, ???

What was that like and how long did it go on?

I was all, okay, you two two boys go do your weeping falling in love thing, I’m going to be over here imagining this whole cadre of dudes who are signing up for cooking classes because they’re competing to become a clan bride to this ‘powerful’ family.

Like, seriously, the thing I lay awake wondering about is, where’s the story of Uno’s family, right? Like, did his papa one day, when he was what, three? (because seriously these two boys aren’t even out of high school) pull him aside and say, “Look, son, you seem… like the sort… and we need the money really desperately… so, I know you thought you might be a fisherman like me and your brothers are. But, your mom and I, we’re going to spend the meager savings we’ve scrapped together over the years so you can learn the art of flower arranging. Do your best! The family is counting on you!”

Instead, the majority of this manga is about hapless Shinji, the younger brother to the heir, who got the VERY BAD NEWS that he’s now going to be forced into a gay marriage for reasons of FAMILY TRADITION.  Luckily, Teh Gay is very catchy, especially when confronted with a boy as beautiful as Uno.

I… yeah, I read the whole volume, even the other stories at the end about other members of this ‘powerful’ family… and I’m not sue why. The sex, what there was of it, was very sappy and heteronormative.

Given what happens in chapter 6 “Even if it Costs my Life,” it seems pretty clear that the Souda are yakuza.  There aren’t any tattoos or anything obvious like that, but in that chapter we follow one of the heirs who needs a bodyguard because people are trying to kill him.  When one of his classmates pulls a knife, she tells him she has to kill him because ever since her father borrowed that money, he has to do whatever the Souda say.


So, it’s get’s better, right? Because now there’s an angle you could use to tell the story of the handsome fisherman’s son I imagined previously with another twist… the mafia family goes trolling for boys they think will make good “wives,” offer money… I mean THIS PRACTICALLY WRITES ITSELF.

And, yet somehow, Hoshino-sensei never, ever wrote the actual story I wanted.

(My gods, am I going to have to ask for Yuletide fic of this one too?)


2 thoughts on “Hanayome-kun / Mr. Flower Bride by Lily Hoshino

  1. Excellent. I could tell I was going to hate it from the tropey dewy eyed bride frontispiece. At least a couple of panels about calling a man ‘onee-san’ I expect?
    A national financial literacy program would really help reduce the number of these personal debt management/estate planning manga plots. (Although somehow I did enjoy most of Zombie Loan.)
    I’m still reeling that your bookstore sells used books. How great is that? Most used bookstores around here were killed by the internet.

    • I kind of thought I might hate it from the title ALONE, but then I thought, “Eh, at these prices, why not?” And, yeah, not only does our B&N have a used book section, we also have several used bookstores in town. SEVERAL. One of them is just up the road from me, Midway Books. http://www.midwaybook.com

      Plus, we’ve got Sixth Chamber Books which sells used children’s books (as well as new) and even our science fiction bookstore in town has a huge used selection. So, yeah, I don’t know why, but Minneapolis/St. Paul still has a very thriving used book business.

      And a financial literacy program might help, but I should have mentioned in my review that there was actually NO REASON given why Uno (the bride) was hot for the job of ‘clan wife’ beyond the whole sappy ‘I have always loved you from afar’ stuff. So, I made up the idea that it was some kind of financial pressure, since maybe I like that scenario better? Like some sick part of me would enjoy the idea that maybe there’s some resistance from the ‘brides’ as well as the reluctant grooms? But that both of them are sufficiently motivated to try to get the thing done, you know? I dunno. I guess if you’re going with the whole forced marriage trope, I feel like you should feel free to go heavier on the FORCE.


      Eh, I’m just twisted.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s